THAT BUSINESS OF MEANING
THAT BUSINESS OF MEANING Podcast
Paul Worthington on Organizations & Identity
0:00
-1:29:29

Paul Worthington on Organizations & Identity

A THAT BUSINESS OF MEANING Conversation

Paul Worthington is a brand consultant and President of Invencion, a strategic advisory practice he founded in 2011. Previously he was Client Principal & Head of Strategy; Strategy Director; and Senior Strategist at Wolff Olins in New York. He writes the newsletter Off Kilter and has written for Fast Company.


I start all of these conversations with the same question and the same little prelude, because I borrowed this beautiful question from a friend of mine. She helps people tell their story. She’s an oral historian. And the question is so beautiful, I stole it from her, but it’s very, very big. So I kind of over-explain it the way that I do now. So before I ask it, I want you to know that you’re in absolute control and you can answer or not answer any way that you want to.

And the question is, where do you come from? Again, you’re in absolute control and you can answer or not answer any way that you want to.

Well, of course, being a born contrarian, my first reaction is to answer that question by saying, where do you come from conceptually in this world that we live in, as opposed to where do I come from physically? But I’ll answer it the old-fashioned way first. I originate from the Shetland Islands in Scotland, which is very far away from anything.

We used to describe it jokingly as the center of the North Sea. It has about 20,000 people and about 300-odd thousand sheep. And I lived there for the first 18 years or so of my life, went to college, and ended up from college being in London.

After working in London, I ended up in New York. And these days you find me 20-odd years later in Connecticut.

What was it like growing up in this, as you say, the center of the North Sea?

Well, funnily enough, I’ll give you a comparison to New York. So the island that I come from is called Unst, and Unst is the very furthest north island in the United Kingdom. You cannot get any further north and still be in the UK.

And it’s on the same latitude as Bergen in Norway, and it’s somewhere a little bit south of the Arctic Circle. Unst is almost exactly the same size and shape as Manhattan. It’s roughly three miles across and 12 miles long, but there’s about 600 people living on it instead of 6 million.

And its claim to fame, funnily enough, is Treasure Island, the book. If you look at the map of Treasure Island, it’s almost the perfect map of Unst. And the reason is that Robert Louis Stevenson’s father was a lighthouse engineer. And when Stevenson was a boy, he spent a whole year or so in Unst while his father was building and overseeing the lighthouse, Muckle Flugga, which is the most northerly lighthouse in the UK.

And so years later, when he wrote Treasure Island, he used his memory of Unst to map out the island in the book.

This is unbelievable. It’s such a particular and unique place to grow up. At what point do you discover how unique it is?

I feel like it’s just how you grew up, but then there must be some moment where you realize, my gosh.

It’s funny, because I think when you’re a kid, you’re very cognizant of how unique it is in all the wrong ways. As a child, I remember distinctly watching the ads every Saturday morning or whatever for things like McDonald’s. Of course, there’s no McDonald’s, or Kentucky Fried Chicken.

So you go on holiday and the first thing you want to do is, I want to go have McDonald’s, because you’ve been watching all these ads for six months and you haven’t been able to consume this horrendous food. So you’re very cognizant in that sense. I think when you get older, you reflect back on it and you realize that it is an incredible place.

It’s funny, being able to go back as a tourist gives you different eyes on a place where you grew up, because you had a very different idea of it as a kid. And it is very beautiful. It has some incredible birdlife.

The sea is right there. Obviously, it has a fishing history. But just being able to go off in a boat and see the cliffs and the seals and the dolphins and occasionally see whales.

You don’t realize at the time, when you’re a kid, how special that is, when you drive down to watch the pod of killer whales in the bay and you can hear them. You don’t realize, when you watch them on film, on TV or YouTube or whatever, that these things are really loud. They’re definitely talking to each other.

But that is a real life history. A long time ago, I came from a very far away place.

And how remote was it? Or how much was there back and forth?

Shetland itself is a 14-hour ferry ride from the mainland of the UK. So you get on the ferry at six in the afternoon and you get off at eight in the morning. It takes about an hour on the airplane. It’s a couple hundred miles offshore.

So it’s pretty remote. But it’s also very connected, because it was the hub of the UK’s oil industry in the 70s. So when I was growing up, it was very connected to the world, because the oil industry is a global industry.

What I’ve realized as I got a bit older is it’s generally much more cosmopolitan than other Scottish islands that are much closer in, if you like, but don’t have that connection to the global economy in the same way.

And do you recall what you wanted to be when you were young, Paul? What did you want to be when you grew up?

That’s a funny question. I think, like a lot of boys of my era, my first love was I wanted to be a fighter pilot. And then I found out that you couldn’t be a fighter pilot and wear glasses.

So I was screwed. My pilot dreams were dashed at a young age when I found out that glasses wearers weren’t allowed to fly at Mach 2.

And so now catch us up. Where are you now? And tell us about the work that you do.

These days, I am in the sunny town of Wilton in Connecticut, about an hour and change north of New York City, living the suburban dream. As anybody who has children in New York will know, it’s a very difficult place, an expensive place. And so you often make the move into the suburbs.

And we did that during the COVID period. And it’s great. Love it.

It’s a nice place to live. In terms of what I do, I would say there’s two things that I do. The first is that my main business is a consulting business.

I do primarily brand strategy consulting. I’d caveat and say that it’s that overlap between company strategy, corporate strategy, and brand strategy, and how you are delivering what the business is trying to achieve through the brand. And it’s very much what is the world of corporate branding.

I prefer to call it organizational branding, because it’s not always a corporation, but it’s typically an organization of some kind. So what you’re not branding is a specific consumer packaged good, product, or service. What you are looking at is what is the combined human endeavor of this organization and what does that ladder up to, and what does that mean as a brand, and how does that potentially umbrella across multiple product and service offerings, but also give people a sense of what’s going to come next and what they should expect in terms of innovation.

And I come from what I would call the organization-out school. I spent 10 years at Wolff Olins in my past. Wally Olins was the pioneer of corporate identity as a concept.

We don’t really use that term anymore, but if you were to read his book from 1989, there’s a direct lineage to how I do what I do, which is that he was really looking at the inside of an organization and saying that an organization has a personality, it has a certain way of being, it has a set of cultural norms, and that you can capture that and then reflect that internal reality into the external world.

And so I think that’s very much my lineage. I’m very much looking at what is it that makes this organization unique? And as a result of what makes this organization unique, what does that mean for a competitive advantage relative to the markets that they serve, relative to the products they might make, relative to the experiences they might create?

It seems like a long-winded way of talking about it, but I think we’ve got to this point where the word brand is almost like the reverse of the word snow for the Inuit. You know how they talk about how the Inuit have over 50 words for snow? Marketers have over 50 definitions for the word brand.

So I come from the corporate identity, organization-out tradition of the branding world. That’s my core business.

I'm certainly part of the problem when it comes to that definition thing. There's some attachment to trying to define it, and I appreciate how clear you're being about it. What more can you say about the lineage, and about the role Wally Olins played in defining this practice of organization out? Is that his language, or your way of differentiating your approach? And what's the alternative to organization out?

Well, I think there’s a couple of things. That’s not his language. That’s certainly my interpretation, just as a clarifying way of describing it.

I think there are multiple schools. And what happens is the schools tend to look at the subject through their own lens, and then they use that lens to define the subject. But the problem is they’re not really defining the subject, they’re defining the piece of the subject that they can see through their particular lens.

So if you’re an advertising planner, or as they call themselves these days, strategists, you’re looking at that from a market-back perspective. Look, what’s the consumer insight that we can attach to this brand that will drive this campaign, that will drive this behavior change, or whatever it is we’re trying to create? And so that then becomes what you might call platform-specific.

They talk about campaign platforms, or it might be campaign-specific, but there’s much more of a market back. So if you deal with most, not all by any stretch, but most advertising strategists, they’re far less interested in what makes the organization itself unique. What they’re really focused on is what’s the external insight that we can attach it to.

If you speak to somebody at Brand Finance, they’re going to view the brand as an intangible financial asset. So what they’re going to do is talk to you about what are all the levers that you might pull to increase the value of the intangible asset. And so it’s another different way of looking at it.

And then if you take somebody like the marketing scientists, and especially the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, they’re looking at a lot of consumer data. They’re looking at purchase pattern behavior. And so they will tend to view the brand as a purchase trigger.

It’s a trigger of purchase. But again, I think all of these things are great, but we have to recognize that when you look at something through a lens, you cannot then define the whole by the lens. So you can have a brand which is organization-out, but that is also market-back, the consumer insight, that is also an intangible financial asset.

And it also works as a purchase trigger. And so you can be all of these things at the same time without narrowing your definition so small as to say, well, that’s what the brand is.

Yes.

That makes sense. I think this is one of the reasons I reached out to you. I found your writing on LinkedIn, and I appreciate how generous your definition is, a plurality of ideas. I appreciate how strategic you are, and how clear you are as a communicator and a thinker. That explanation is really quite amazing. My follow-up: when did you first discover that you could make a living doing this kind of thing, organizational branding?

Yes. I’ll tell you a funny story. I hadn’t put this together, but I went to college as an undergraduate in the early nineties, ended up doing various things in the Highlands of Scotland, and applied for a job at the Stewart Formula One team, which existed at that time, Jackie Stewart, the great Scottish racing legend.

And so I applied for this job and they turned me down. And I remember looking at the rejection letter, and looking at my resume at the time, and being like, shit, I would have turned me down too. I gotta do something here.

So I went back to college and I did an MBA. And then I graduated my MBA and I was applying for jobs and literally nobody would hire me. And again, I had the same feeling that I’d had at the end of my undergraduate, right?

Which is, this effing degree is not even worth the paper it’s printed on. Anyway, I saw an ad for Wolff Olins advertising for senior strategy consultants, which wouldn’t have included me. And I had always followed the company from an early age in terms of my professional development, because there’d been certain brands that had hit the market in the UK: Orange, the cell phone company.

There was a credit card called Goldfish. There was a discount airline from British Airways at the time, competing with EasyJet, called Go. And these things just blew my mind, because they were so different from anything else.

You had this cell phone company that never showed a cell phone in any of its ads and kept talking about the future and optimism. And I was like, that’s incredible. And then there was this credit card company that wasn’t selling on the basis of status and silver, platinum, gold.

And it was funny. And it was irreverent, and I’m like, wow, an irreverent credit card. I just love that.

And then Go was just this incredibly happy, joyful thing. And it was very much inspired, I suspect, by the spot paintings of Damien Hirst. And so I looked up and I found that the common thread between these three brands was Wolff Olins.

And I remember now, I didn’t even realize at the time, but I actually studied Wally’s book at college in my undergraduate years. And I’ve always been very obsessed with that idea of brands marketing: why would people pay more for this thing because it’s branded and not branded? It’s just an interesting intellectual question.

So anyway, I was in this mode of complete desperation. And so I wrote literally the cheekiest application letter. And I can’t remember everything it said, but three things I do remember. First, I wrote the whole thing.

And then at the end, I went back and I bolded the key points. And then I wrote at the top of the letter, I know you’re really busy, so just read the bold bits. And then the second thing I said was, I’m not asking you for a job.

I’m just asking you for an interview. I don’t need the job. I just need a chance.

And then the last thing I did was, they said they wanted outside-the-box thinkers. And this is one of those ones you look back on in the hubris of youth, but I remember writing, before you can think outside the box, you have to accept that there is a box. I know that there is no box.

Anyway, so I wrote this, got an interview, got a job. And so then here I am in my mid-twenties working for this company, the only company I’d ever actually wanted to work for, that did these things that I found amazing. Then in hindsight, I realized that I’d actually studied it at college, and obviously it had some subconscious impact.

And I didn’t even know that this thing called brand consulting existed at the time. I had no idea there were other companies who even did this. I got the job at Wolff Olins not even knowing that the likes of FutureBrand or Interbrand, any of these companies, existed, because I just wasn’t even interested in it as a field.

I was just interested in working for this one company. And I was really fortunate. I got to work there for a decade. So it was great.

How would you describe the thing that you were attracted to? What was happening that you were like, oh my God, I need to be in this?

It’s very amusing, because I was there 2001 through 2011 before I left to do my own thing. And at various points in that 10-year period, you have these conversations amongst yourselves around, what is the secret sauce? What is the magic?

Because obviously there is generational change. The people who were there leave, the people who are new join, and it changes, right? So you’re always asking, what’s the thread? And we never could quite figure it out, I don’t think.

And it’s funny, because I had a client once who told me this great line I use all the time. He said, you can’t read the label from inside the jar. And it’s so true.

But I think in hindsight, looking back on it, there were a couple of things that were super important. The first was the work was inherently joyful. Everything that was coming out at that time, in that period of the late nineties through the early thousands, when I was just joining, there was just an insane amount of happiness and joy to the work, which was really notable amongst the pretty dour branded environment of the time.

It was the back end of the nineties. Everything felt like it was going down as opposed to going up. The dot-com crash had happened. You had the Cool Britannia, the political movement at the time.

Cool Britannia was coming to an end. And so here’s this thing running totally opposite to that.

I think the other thing in hindsight, it’s funny, is that there was this fervent, almost ideological belief that you had to stand for something, that you don’t stand out unless you stand for something, and that you need to stand for something really special. I think that gets a bit funny, because in hindsight, I was thinking about this the other day. It’s like, well, Valens at that time, the idea of standing for something was so powerful, and it attracted very type A people who believed very much in standing for something.

And I think the challenge is that everybody stood for something different. The unifying force was everybody fervently believed that you had to stand for something. The fragmenting force that weakened its impact was that everybody felt like you had to stand for something different from everybody else.

Which is great when you’re consulting to clients, right? Because those are very different lenses. And so the right people applied to the right clients creates magic.

But it really is the herding-cats-on-the-inside mentality that you’ve all heard about. So it’s a wonderful place. I have great memories of it.

I wish it nothing but success. And I look back on its dysfunctions much more charitably than I did when I left in 2011.

You said cheeky, and you used the word hubris, but I have to note that my career started with a very arrogant cover letter, to a brand consulting firm. I couldn't have written a normal one if I tried. I won't spend too much time on it, but I remember signing off "I look forward to hearing from you" after taking some rather provocative positions on the mediocrity of everything I'd encountered in my days in San Francisco.

Well, it’s funny though, when you look back on these things. I remember after working there for about six months or a year, I had this moment where I was like, I had no idea at the time, but that desperation-fueled cover letter that I wrote could not have been more perfectly optimized for that particular recipient. There was nobody in Wolff Olins that wouldn’t have at least acknowledged a letter like that, because it fit so much with the personality of the place. But at the time you’re writing it, it’s like, well, I’ve been turned down by everybody else.

I’ve got nothing to lose. This is it, right? I’ll give you a really funny story.

I actually applied to McKinsey twice in my life as a student, around about a similar time. The first time I got no response at all. The second time I was rejected a year later. I was like, wow, that’s impressive.

You sent me a rejection letter a full calendar year after I applied to you. That’s impressive.

How do you even process that?

I don’t know. All kidding aside, I suspect I’m not sure I would have enjoyed my professional life as much had I ended up at McKinsey.

You dodged a bullet. When you think about the work that you do, what do you love about it? Where is the joy in the work that you do for you?

Well, there’s two things. There’s really two sides to the work that I do these days, because I’d include the newsletter I write, Off Kilter, as work, even though I don’t get paid for it.

And I take joy from the consulting work and that work in different ways. The joy that I take in the consulting work, and it’s the joy that I’ve always taken, is I’m super fascinated by the intellectual problem of figuring out what it is that this client needs help with. Whenever a client writes an RFP or has a verbal brief or has whatever problem they’re trying to solve, they very rarely understand the reality of what the problem is.

It’s kind of like, imagine if you’re a builder in a house and somebody’s like, yeah, there’s something wrong with the pipes. We know there’s something wrong with the pipes because there’s no water coming out, but we don’t know what’s wrong with the pipes. And so the plumbers come in, rip out the wall, rip out the pipes in order to find out where the problem is.

And so I think often what happens is that they can diagnose they have a problem, but they don’t know where exactly that problem is starting and finishing, and hence what you need to do. So I really have always enjoyed the intellectual challenge of really diagnosing the problem and then working with the client to get to a better answer, to get to something that is going to be useful for them. I’ve always been far more driven by making this work really well for the people who are hiring me to do the job. This is for them, for the client.

Because I think there’s a world we live in where people get obsessed with awards and they get obsessed with being praised by their peers. And that’s never really been something I’ve been all that interested in. I’ve always been like, this is a really interesting intellectual problem, let me solve it.

And let me work with my client to help them get to a better place ultimately. I think there’s a certain craft to being an advisor. I never have the accountability or responsibility for making the decisions, which I’m very conscious of. It’s not my job. So what I can’t ever do is tell my client they must do anything.

That’s entirely wrong. But there’s a certain freedom that not having that responsibility and accountability gives you, if you’re a responsible advisor, in which case you can bring things to them that they may not otherwise have thought of. And they may not choose to do those things.

But the fact that you’re bringing that to them and saying, well, here’s why this is something that would make sense for you, often helps them break out of their own mental lock-in and think, actually, we’re not X kind of company, we’re actually Y kind of company. I dealt with a client many years ago now, and they very much thought of themselves as, we’re a book publisher, we’re a publishing company. And then through the work that I did with them, I helped them understand that they’re not actually in the book publishing business, they were in the learning business, because the books they were publishing were used by people to learn how to do things.

And the problem they had wasn’t the quality of the learning in the book. The problem was that the package of a book was no longer relevant in a world where people are doing everything online. And so what we needed to find was, how do we liberate the knowledge that’s inside the book from the format itself? Which means you’re not really a publisher, you’re a learning company.

And that really helped them unlock a lot of innovation and drive them toward really focusing their business much more on how do we make sure we have the learning for people who want it, in the format they want it, meet them where they are, rather than continue to push this business model, which very clearly had a half-life that was compressing. So I think that’s what I love about the core of what I do. It’s, how do you solve these very interesting intellectual problems?

When you do work with clients, how do you go about diagnosing the problem? And how do you define the problem? There’s a selfish part of this for me always. As a researcher, I’m always wondering how people discover and how they learn. But how do you go about defining the problem for a client and diagnosing, whatever the relationship is between those two ideas?

Yeah. I think the first thing is that there’s certain things that are pretty standard. We consultants and consulting firms often like to put a lot of weight into, we have a proprietary process for uncovering insight X or investigating Y. And some of those tools can be quite useful, but in general, they’re just masking fairly basic things: really understanding what business the company is in, what the nature of the business problem that it may have is, because typically people who are super successful and doing great don’t generally hire consultants to come in and help them.

So usually there is some problem somewhere. It’s one of those things where it’s like, I know my arm hurts, but I don’t know whether I have a sprained arm or whether I have a broken arm. And whether your arm is sprained or broken leads to a very different solution in terms of fixing it. So I think that there’s often that kind of thing going on.

So from a pure process standpoint, it’s understanding all of the available research they have, speaking to internal stakeholders. And one of the key things that I always insist on with my clients is speaking to some of their customers. And it’s interesting how a lot of companies these days don’t speak to their customers very often. They have a ton of behavioral data, and they use that often as a proxy.

They may do quantitative studies and surveys, and they may have, especially in B2B, a sales team or a customer success team that interacts with clients. But in terms of actually speaking to their clients and having a conversation like this, you’d be surprised how rare it is.

Wow. And is that something you’ve noticed has changed over the years? There’s a piece of me that assumes that that’s the case. There’s this cliche that we’re drowning in data, but we don’t have any understanding. You know what I mean? Is it true that people aren’t talking to their customers as much?

I think it is a truism, but two things. One is I think it’s absolutely a trend. And I’ve witnessed it over my career, that it is becoming less and less likely that companies will have spent any or much effort on the qualitative side of understanding the customers.

And when you insist upon it, they’ll often push back and say, well, you don’t really need that information. We have a ton of customer data. And so you will say, well, let me see what you’ve got.

And you look and you say, this isn’t what I need. I need to speak to your clients. And it’s rarely a limiting factor.

But I have turned down client engagements for this reason, where I was like, I cannot help you if you don’t let me speak to your clients.

Oh, my God. That’s amazing. What’s your sense of their experience? Do you feel like they are suffering as a result of this disconnect?

Yeah. I think the truism, as I mentioned, is we’ve never known more about what customers do. And we’ve never understood less about why they do it.

Yeah, that’s perfect.

And I think that’s very real. And I find that very, very commonly when I feed back to clients. Obviously it’s an interpretive lens that I use, but I will say, here’s what I’m hearing from your clients.

And it’s often surprising.

I’m so interested. Can you say more? How do you approach that? I’ve been in that situation, too. How do you approach the interviews? And then how do you approach delivering to the client this sense of what you’ve learned, to somebody that maybe hasn’t talked to their customers in ages?

Very importantly, it’s very dependent upon the nature of the client engagement, right? There’s some engagements where the scale and complexity of the organization necessitates working with, say, an external third-party research organization. So I’ll exclude that from my answer, just because that’s a different kind of thing.

What I want to do with any client, small or large, is what I would refer to as exploratory quals. Meaning, I’m not going in there and asking the same questions of the same customers. I’m going in there and I’m exploring with customers.

And then when I hear things that seem valuable, I will test those things with another customer. So, I’ve spoken to somebody and they had this to say, what do you think of that? And so for me, it’s not about research purity, because my output is not a research report.

It’s about how do I help shape and understand the nature of the problem that this client has? It’s almost part of that diagnostic process. So that when I come back to them, we’re able to say, let’s look at the shape of your business problem through the lens of what the customers are experiencing and how they’re viewing what’s happening in the market.

And sometimes that will mean that you might overemphasize something which has quite a small sample size related to it, but it has a direct correlation to what the client is trying to solve for or create or whatever it might be. So yeah, it’s very much a sense-making exercise. And what often I’m trying to do is really frame the problem in a way perhaps the client hasn’t previously thought about it.

Yeah. How would you describe what you’re doing in those conversations, in those exploratory interviews? Do you have any tricks of the trade? How would you describe the way that you approach them, or how you are in them, without asking you to give away too much?

No, no, it’s fine. I don’t view it as proprietary at all. I don’t think that’s a useful framing.

I’m trying to think about it, because I haven’t really thought about it in a long time, because it’s just something I’ve done for a long time. Yeah. Generally speaking, I try not to walk in with too many predefined questions.

I generally have topics that I want to explore with the person that I’m talking to, and based on how they respond, I will either go, oh, let’s go down that path a little deeper, or let’s go down this path. Generally speaking, you’ll understand the nature of what the client is trying to solve for, and that could be, we’re not growing, we need to grow, or the market’s changed and we need to understand how to respond, or we’re looking to create a new brand to go do something that we haven’t done before. So the nature of the problem will shape the specifics of the flow.

But generally speaking, what I’m trying to do is have a conversation first that’s driven by a lot of active listening, where I’m happy for the conversation to go in one of potentially very different directions, because I don’t know where that customer is coming from. And then as you do more and more of them, you’re starting to build patterns and understand where there’s alignment, but you don’t necessarily draw your conclusions from the patterns. Sometimes you draw your conclusions from the edge cases, because sometimes those edge cases are actually things which are far more aligned to what you see as the opportunity for that client.

And then of course, down the line, you have further conversations about validation, and whether you do additional exploration or whether you do more formalized research based on that exploration. There’s a lot of potential outcomes from that.

I enjoy exploring first principles, even though it can be indulgent, and I wanted to ask about brand. You were saying earlier that it’s like the elephant: everybody looks at brand through their own lens and defines it by that lens. I know you’ve written about this a bunch, but when did you first encounter the idea of brand, and how do you define it or talk about it now in a useful way?

Well, I think as a consumer, I’ve encountered brands my whole life. Professionally, what made me interested is very geeky, so my apologies. When I was an undergraduate, I remember very distinctly, I did economics as one course and I had marketing as another course.

And in economics, they’re talking about rational economic man and perfect information and that price is dictated by competition. Unless you’re a monopolist, there’s no excess profit. And then you go into marketing class and they’re saying, yeah, so what we’re going to do is we’re going to build this brand, and it’s going to create a price premium, because people are going to want to buy this ahead of buying the commodity, and da, da, da, da, da.

And I was like, wait a minute, these two things seem very oppositional to each other. And so in a very naive way, as a young person who’s not been familiar with these topics before, when you’re first learning about them, I made that contrast and went, I’m really interested in this brand thing, because it seems to mess with what the economics lecturer has been telling me. And I like that idea a lot.

“It messed with it.”

I didn’t want to swear.

And how do you define it now? What does it mean to you now?

Oh, I’m going to give you a non-answer answer.

Good. Perfect.

I’ve spent probably the last 20-plus years of my career trying really, really hard not to define the word brand.

Perfect.

Because I think we waste too much time in definitions, and everybody has their own version. What I find far more valuable is to talk about the economic impact of brands versus not brands. So if you think about what a brand delivers for you, not defining it, it decreases the cost of customer acquisition, which is a known effect.

It increases the potential for a price premium, which is a known effect, which drives profitability. It also, and this is something that I spend a lot of time on, which is not covered as much in the literature, builds customer permission for the company to create a certain kind of value. And what that customer permission does is it de-risks the costs of innovation.

So if you’re Apple and you have the iPhone, which is successful, and you’re a brand which is trusted for all things consumer electronics, it de-risks your market entry with AirPods, for example. Or if you’re Lego, the success of Lego de-risks the addition of new IP partners and licensing deals for new kinds of Lego sets. Amazon is an interesting one, right?

Its success as an online retailer at scale actually gave it a permission that de-risked its shift into cloud computing. Not because you’re like, oh, if they can deliver this, they can also deliver cloud computing. It’s more of a conversation where you say, if you can deliver compute power to a company at the scale of Amazon, and build an infrastructure that can serve a company at the scale of Amazon, then it is legitimate that you could do it for others. So I think one of the things that we do not talk enough about is the future economic value that customer permission de-risks through innovation.

So I’m way more interested in starting with the effects on the business of having these things. They operate like demand-side monopolies, demand-side moats, if you want to put it that way. There’s a lot of ways you can frame them. And then from a definitional standpoint, to a certain degree, I don’t care.

I don’t care if one client has a different definition of what a brand is compared to another, as long as it works for them. What is important is you don’t have competing definitions within the same company. It’s destructive when you have a CFO, a CEO, a CMO, a head of HR. If all those people have a very different perspective and understanding of what a brand is, and hence what a brand does, then that becomes really destructive. If company A and company B have two very different conceptions of it, it doesn’t matter.

I love the way you're talking about this, because it avoids all the other language. It's so precise, and the permission idea is so interesting as well. How much has that changed over your career? With all the shifts that are happening, has it stayed consistent, or how do we evaluate it as things change?

I think that we have made a series of category errors inside the marketing function that have direct connotations for brand as a concept. And I generally view brands through the big lens of: everything you do as a company has a direct implication on how your brand exists. So I don’t like it when we talk about brand as just an advertising construct that is somehow disconnected from the underlying proposition.

I don’t like it when we talk about brand as a marketing-science purchase trigger that also is disconnected from the underlying purpose. The more disconnected we treat it, the worse it is. What I think has happened over the years is, unfortunately, we have massively narrowed the aperture of the intellectual discourse around marketing.

And as a result, we keep narrowing the idea of what it is. So I’ll give you a couple of examples. When we frame marketing through the lens of ROI, that isn’t just language, and it isn’t just a metric.

It’s actually an epistemological condition. When I say epistemological, because I sometimes have to explain that to people, it’s, how do we know what is true? It is a philosophical lens.

And so, when you’re looking at everything through the lens of ROI in marketing, it’s actually a measure of efficiency. It’s the efficiency of the thing that we intend to spend money on. And the other thing it has to have is it has to be predictable, meaning we have to know ahead of time roughly what that efficiency is.

And that’s what the ROI gives us. Now, operationally, that can be useful. If I’ve got two tactics that I want to run, and I want to decide whether I should run tactic A or tactic B, ROI is a useful metric.

Strategically, it’s an absolutely disastrous metric, because what happens is you cannot do anything where you do not have an already predefined understanding of its ROI. So, if we take that to its ultimate conclusion, it’s things like, well, we’d never, ever introduce a new product, because we don’t know how many of those products we would sell. Or we might not explore a new marketing channel until a lot of other people have already explored it and we have benchmarked ROI numbers.

But we’re not going to touch it at all. And so I think what it does is it fundamentally narrows the aperture of what marketing is and can be, because it can only be things that we’ve effectively been doing before. It can’t be the thing we need it to be, which is to explore into new sources of customer value.

So that’s one way of narrowing it. Another way we’ve narrowed it is the field of marketing science, which is extremely useful academically. It gives us empirical generalizations.

This is what tends to happen to most brands in most situations under certain market conditions.

And at this point, are we talking Ehrenberg-Bass? Is this How Brands Grow, or is it broader than that?

Yeah, there’s a much broader field of marketing science, but in terms of use by practitioners, I think the Ehrenberg-Bass lens is the predominant lens these days.

This is about, you’ve written about this, the availability trap.

So here’s the way I would look at it. There’s nothing that is extremely useful to have marketing scientists give us empirical generalizations. It is very useful to know what tends to happen to most brands in most markets under certain conditions. Where it becomes dangerous is when we equate that with a universal prescription of what everybody should do.

And there’s a very easy reason for that, which is that it is giving you the averages of what tends to happen. Our job as marketers should be to try to figure out how do we make sure that our company is not average. We want to exceed the average of performance.

And if we want to exceed the average of performance, then you have to look at where you are either seeking to break the pattern of a generalization, or you’re seeking to combine something in a new way, or seeking to move very high up a distribution, away from the average of that distribution. And I think this is really important, because when we look at market-level generalities and then we equate that to a strategy, by definition, we have now limited ourselves to operating within the average. And whenever you look at any high-performing corporation ever, it’s always because it has exceeded the average in some way, shape, or form.

So I have no problem with the academic work at all. I think it’s extremely useful and helpful.

What I have a big problem with is when we interpret that as being the boundaries of possibility. The analogy I use is a bit like saying gravity exists, so that creates the boundaries of possibility for transportation, which means we can only ever have ground transportation. And so if the Wright brothers had been marketers in the modern environment, they would never have invented the aircraft.

Right. That’s wonderful.

And I think that that’s the problem. We are massively limiting our possibilities, because we are constraining our lens to things like the marketing science perspective, instead of saying that is one data point, and there is potentially a lot more we should draw from.

And where do you turn for the kinds of marketing science that can lead you towards those possibilities?

Again, I think it’s an epistemological question, right? I think it’s less about where do we look for science. I think it’s more about how do we choose to treat science as practitioners.

And so I look at it through the lens that science in marketing is a broad church, and that it should expand our possibility space, not constrain it. And so we owe it to ourselves. We’re in the business of customer value creation.

Customers are human beings, they’re people. And so we should be broadly drawing from the science that deals with human beings, which means we should be drawing from sociology, we should be drawing from anthropology, we should be drawing from consumer psychology, we should be drawing from behavioral economics, we should be drawing from innovation theory. As soon as you go away from saying, this is the limit of my possibility, and instead say, actually, there’s a much broader field of science that could potentially inform how we choose to build strategies to be non-average as opposed to just average, I think it’s quite liberating.

And I think it gets us back closer to what used to be. And I don’t mean to look at this through the lens of shitstalgia, which I love, that term. I didn’t come up with it, but I read it somewhere, somebody had written it. It’s the idea that when you look back at the past, you think it’s so much better than today, even though it was actually shit.

But I think what we did have, which was useful, was a lot of intellectual pluralism in the marketing environment. There were a lot of ideas, and a lot of theories, and a lot of things actually that were quite robust academically.

What are you thinking about, or what are you calling to mind?

So if I think about the likes of, well, Olson Zaltman still exists, right? So Jerry Olson and his partner, I can’t remember his first name. But if you look at what they did, they have a patented method for metaphor and meaning from, I don’t know, 30, 40 years ago.

They still utilize it in Olson Zaltman, but it’s now a small niche company rather than something that is broadly utilized as a potential tool by marketers. You think about the consumer psychology that I learned in marketing in college. You think about even Kotler. And then of course, the marketing scientists will unbask that and say, well, it’s not empirically provable, and what have you.

And I’m like, well, that’s fine. But there’s other marketing scientists that will challenge you and say that you are ignoring 60 years of marketing science in order to put forth your own narrow perspective. So I think this idea that this narrow, Ehrenberg-Bass-focused idea of what marketing science is, is settled, is actually wrong.

There are plenty of marketing academics out there that would happily challenge that and say it’s not. They’ll tell you that there’s a lot of value in the underlying research, and they will also tell you that it has been selectively chosen in order to fuel a set of theories which don’t particularly hold up either.

So interesting. Keep going.

Yeah, I was just going to say, there’s a professor at Said Business School in London who analyzed, I think, in excess of 1,000 case studies to try to see if there was proof of the Ehrenberg-Bass idea of market asset theory compared to positioning, and they couldn’t find any proof. Empirically, you couldn’t find proof that it’s a superior approach. So all I mean to say by that is, I don’t want to get into an academic fight.

All I think is, if you are a practitioner, you should view all of these things as tools. And in your tool bag, why limit yourself to a chisel when you might need a hammer or a saw or a measuring tape? We should have a much broader toolkit that we’re willing to draw from.

And it is our judgment as practitioners as to which of those tools we bring out, depending on the situation that we’re in.

I was just at a strategy event in the city and had a wonderful conversation with a strategist I’ve talked to before, who is a real champion of the laws. He uses the word “law.” Is it the binomial and the banana? The reach chart from Ehrenberg.

The story I tell about this is that behaviorism took over a lot of marketing culture, and there’s just not much curiosity about the humanities or the social sciences. We just want to look at things from the outside and track the behavior. It’s a very mechanical, behaviorist view of human experience. It doesn’t have much room for the kinds of things I feel you’re pointing at, which were part of how I came up, and which are what fascinates me about the whole task of trying to understand human behavior in the market.

Yeah. So the first thing is, I get very uncomfortable with using terms like laws. I think there’s been a movement in the social sciences to try not to define things too strictly in terms of laws, because the social sciences often suffer from the challenge of irrepeatability.

Gravity is gravity. You don’t measure gravity five times and get five different answers. Unless you’re moving to different parts of the world, but that’s a different story.

But I think what that means is, when we use laws, what we do as marketers is we create boundary conditions. We say, well, that is a law. That means it’s a boundary.

That means you cannot do anything outside of that boundary. And the truth is, normally the empirical generalization that is used to dictate what that law is has a wide distribution. And when you have a wide distribution and you’re only looking at the mean, you’re ignoring all the statistical outliers.

And in my experience, often the value ultimately lies in the variance, right? It lies in the places that don’t gather around the average. And so I think we’ve done ourselves a disservice there.

And I sometimes use the analogy that in sports, we have tons of data. And so we know the averages. We know in baseball what tends to happen in most games most of the time under certain conditions. And we don’t care about those.

We’re only interested in the variances. We’re only interested in the statistical outliers, because that’s where you win games. And I think weirdly, in marketing, we’ve inverted this, right?

So I think that’s there. The other thing on your question, though, is the behaviorist point. I think there’s been tremendous pressure on marketers to conform to the way businesses run these days.

And businesses are run under this data-driven, very quantitatively oriented approach, where we’ve really removed as much qualitative variance as possible from all management decision-making, to the point where we’re actually, I’ve coined a term for this, which is measureship, which is that we’ve bastardized leadership and we’ve handed it over to metrics as opposed to judgment. And marketing was often seen as airy-fairy, sloppy, not focused, whatever, whatever. Lots of things get said about it.

And a lot of it’s true, fine. I’m not denying that reality. And so, in order to make it more disciplined and more empirical, and make it seem more serious and valuable to others inside the organization who are much more quantitative, all the pressure is to pursue ROI as the meaningful metric, because it feels like it’s a legitimate measure, even though it’s actually entirely the wrong metric, and there’s a shit ton of other metrics that are legitimate business metrics we could be using instead. And then there’s this idea that the science, the empiricism of it, is provable.

And so if you’re fighting for a budget and you can use some empiricism from somebody like Byron Sharp or whoever else, and that helps you get your budget through, well, of course you’re going to do that, right? So I think there’s a bit of that going on. The measureship thing, the way I frame it is, we often talk about how algorithms have flattened culture and consumer culture, but they’ve also flattened management.

When you take away the qualitative understanding of customers, employees, other stakeholders, shareholders, when you take away all the human understanding and you just look at it through behavioral numbers and quant, and then you algorithmically deal with that, you just flatten all the context. As I said earlier, we know what’s happening. We have absolutely no idea why.

It’s unbelievable. I’m totally aligned. I’ve been in meetings where leadership doesn’t really even know how to process the kinds of things that I’m sharing with them, the output from qualitative. It’s like a literacy problem when it comes to qualitative data, at a really fundamental level.

It’s a trend. It is literacy. It’s also a translation problem, because if you’re speaking the language of quantitative data and understanding, and somebody comes along with the language of qualitative understanding, those two things don’t necessarily align very easily.

Funnily enough, it’s an area where I think AI becomes quite useful. And the reason is that, for all its problems, it’s a technology which is like a pattern-matching savant. And so its ability to translate between very different domains, like qualitative to quantitative, is actually quite interesting and quite valuable.

And so I think there’s things there that might actually be quite useful in helping people. I think the other thing to point out, and this is a silly aside, but I think it’s quite useful in the marketing environment, right? Think about the companies that build consumer products that are addictive.

They’re the same people building dashboards for marketers that they’re addicted to. I don’t think that is a coincidence.

Unpack that for me. I’m not seeing it. I feel like it’s so clear.

If you’re Google or Meta, you have an insane amount of behavioral data on what will get somebody to click on, watch longer, engage, never leave the infinite scroll.

You’re saying the dashboard is no more than an addictive product.

The dashboard utilizes exactly the same mechanics, because it is deeply ingrained in the culture of those companies. At this point, that is how they think and what they do and how it works, because it’s so fundamental to their business model. And so it just makes all the sense in the world that, of course, they want those same addictive qualities in the dashboards that people are utilizing to make marketing choices and decisions.

So if you’re an executive and you’re bemoaning your child who spends their entire life on TikTok and Instagram Reels, but you’re also addicted to your dashboard and you have to keep looking at it every five minutes, same thing.

I'm always looking to advocate for qual, or to understand its role and its proper place, and I'm curious how you see that role in the age of AI. A few years ago a colleague challenged me. He asked, what would you tell a CMO to make them want to invest in qual in an age of synthetic data and panels and AI? It got existential for me pretty quickly, and I'm still uncertain about it. How do you think about the role of ethnography and qualitative consumer research in this new age of synthetic everything?

I think every company is going to make a different set of choices relative to how it adds insight into what it does. I think where synthetic insight is going to be useful is where it enables companies to do things that they simply could not do before through traditional analysis and insight. So things where you need extremely fast decision-making, things where you need to understand things that are happening that are instantaneous, where you don’t have time to go and do a deeper understanding. There’s things there, but I think those things are all fundamentally quite tactical.

I think the big mistake that’s going to be made, is already being made, and will continue to be made, is this idea that a synthetic insight is equivalent to a human insight. We have lots of evidence to prove already that it is not.

What do you mean when you say a synthetic insight? It’s just an insight generated from a synthetic?

So, for example, I’m not talking about an AI avatar doing customer research with a real human being. That’s a different thing. What I’m talking about is something where it’s purely derived: sources of data from the internet are put into an LLM, and then it creates a synthetic version of a consumer out the other side.

And what’s very interesting is, academically, the finding is that these so-called digital twins are not even remotely close to what people really think. They tend to be overly rational. They tend to be overly descriptive of the very functional, very rational.

And imagine it quick, because obviously a machine does not have and cannot process emotions. And so we as human beings are often quite irrational, actually, and the machine flattens all that irrationality. And so what’s interesting then is what’s left. There’s certainly areas where it might be equivalent. So people will say things like, oh, my AI synthetic, whatever, is 80% as accurate as a human respondent.

I don’t know how they figured that out, but let’s just take them at face value. Well, if it’s 80% the same as the human respondent, the chances are that the 80% is the piece that everybody else already has access to. Right?

And because synthetic insights are non-proprietary and are just available to all, it just creates a new baseline. If it’s a new baseline, there’s no competitive advantage to be had. So what that means is all the advantage has to lie in the 20% variance.

And that 20% variance is where the stuff that’s valuable is going to be, the stuff that isn’t just widely available. So I look at this very, very specifically. I think that what happens in a world of AI is it makes qualitative understanding of the consumer vastly more valuable than it has ever been before, because it is the only source where you are going to have proprietary insight into your customers compared to everybody you compete with, assuming that they’re all moving synthetically.

And what I would say is going to happen with the more enlightened corporations is they’re going to use AI to remove a lot of production costs in what they do. That is going to change the way in which resources are allocated, because it frees up resources that used to be spent on production for other things. And one of the things that frees those resources up to do is to be invested in consumer qualitative understanding.

And so I actually think that it creates a lot of potential to do more and more varied forms of consumer research. And one of the reasons why that’s valuable, actually, is because you can feed it back into the AI and have it help you make sense of it all and pattern match. And if you can pattern match across ethnography, across deep metaphor research, across traditional focus groups, across whatever, and start to build a picture of where the variances are in what you’re hearing, and what the edge cases look like, and what a deeper understanding of what people are looking for might be, it’s very useful.

Because I think we forget that. I think what the synthetic groups are going to do is push us toward functional value, which makes sense because of the lack of capacity to process emotions. I think what the smart companies will do is actually expand their aperture, because value to human beings could be identity value, it could be social value, it could be emotional value. It could be so many different things that we find valuable and meaningful to ourselves.

And they’re so variable by category too, right? They have to be bespoke.

Exactly. Here’s another thing I think is worth looking at. Anybody who’s providing you with synthetic insights, I think the first question you have to ask is, what are your sources? Because so many sources of insight online are actually blocked from these crawlers.

So if they’re telling you that I basically get it exclusively from Reddit and whatever is available on the open internet, well, I don’t know about you, but my experience is that online commentary does not reflect society as a whole.

No, no, that’s also been pretty clearly demonstrated as well. And I feel like there was a moment there where everybody was just feeding on Reddit like crazy. Because again, everybody’s feeding at the same table.

Well, here’s a really dystopian situation that is very real. There is this new group of companies out there who offer GEO services, which is generative engine optimization instead of search engine optimization. And what a lot of them are doing, if you scratch the surface, is they seed content into platforms that they know the LLMs scrape and that provide authority.

So let’s just use Reddit as an example. You want your brand to come up in a specific way in the LLM. So you seed all this content into Reddit, which it scrapes, and then it pattern matches, and then it will present those ideas to the consumer.

And ChatGPT and others have done things like de-rate Reddit, and then that screws it all up. But I’m not talking about that. Just imagine that that is successful.

So now you’re doing your synthetic insights, and that synthetic insight company is drawing from Reddit. So now you’re doing market research which is telling you that the things you seeded into Reddit are consumer truths, not things that you seeded into the platform. That’s a real reality.

And it gets worse.

What do you make of that GEO stuff? I had a conversation with Jess Graham, and she had a beautiful way of putting it: two things can't be true at the same time. One is that we don't really understand how these things work, that the LLM is still a black box. The other is that we know how to build a brand in it. What you're describing seems to be what's being pitched.

I think the easy way to frame it is that it’s the Wild West. And we’ve had plenty of Wild Wests in the last 20 years in the shift to digital. So I think we know what that means.

It means there’s a lot of rhetoric, a lot of snake oil. It’s very difficult to find the signal in the noise. And I’m not saying there’s no signal there. All I’m saying is that there’s a ton of noise.

What I’ve looked at and what I’ve seen is, number one, if you’re already doing a really good job of building your brand, you are de facto typically going to show up at a higher rate inside the LLMs when they’re asked for recommendations.

A well-managed brand is a well-managed brand.

A well-managed brand is a well-managed brand, meaning it’s drawing from multiple sources. And there’s a lot of reinforcing information, and pattern matching, that’s saying that this company is very good at what it does. So if you ask for a safe car, it’ll suggest Volvo.

Why? Because Volvo has spent 20 years, 30 years, 50 years building and marketing the safest cars. So I think that is just the reality.

I think on the flip side, we have the GEO folks. I think they’re a little bit of Band-Aid and Sellotape, and a lot of it is very spurious. And a lot of it, frankly, is a little bit ethically dubious, because it’s seeding content into places that they know are authoritative.

And that content does not have to be real or accurate. So one of the groups that have seeded heavily into Reddit are peptide hawkers. And they seed all this information about peptides, because the LLMs are a huge source on which peptides people should take and how they should take them.

And people don’t realize that that’s actually a sales and marketing effort on behalf of the people hawking these gray-market-at-best compounds. So there’s that, which is challenging. I think on the flip side, what we’re almost certainly going to see, and we’ve seen this exact pattern play out in the technologies that have existed before, is all of the people selling GEO services are going to get deprecated by the platforms themselves.

And then the platforms are going to make it pay to play. So ChatGPT, probably. Anthropic says they’ll never do advertising, but there’s a huge asterisk beside that, because how do you define advertising? I think the economic pressure on all of these things is that they will be monetizing.

So you as a brand will effectively be monetizing how you show up in the LLMs. Because we saw that before, the shift from SEO to SEM, we’re going to see the same shift from GEO to GEM. It’s coming. And it’s not search engine marketing, it’s actually search engine monetization. And the same thing is going to happen to the LLMs.

Beautiful. So we’re at the end of time. Maybe just to open it up, what are you thinking about or looking forward to in the coming weeks and months? What’s on your plate?

I don’t think I think that far ahead. I’m actually genuinely curious. If we push out maybe a little bit further, if we think about the AI conversation, if we remove all of the stuff about rogue agents destroying the world, and we just focus more on how it’s being applied within corporations, I’m really looking forward to the moment where we shift gears from productivity and efficiency to using it to create new things that we couldn’t have done before. We always go through this cycle with technologies, right? We did it with digital.

We took analog documents and we turned them into PDFs. And we called it digital transformation. And then the document becomes interactive.

And then the document goes away and it becomes an alert. At the beginning of digital, I used to get a bank statement in the mail every month. And now I get transaction alerts on my watch.

And so it just changes radically over time. And so I’m really looking forward to that moment where we switch gears and it’s like, oh, guess what? It’s not about automating this existing process after all.

It’s about doing this completely different thing that we couldn’t do before.

Yeah. Beautiful. Well, Paul, I want to thank you so much for joining me and accepting the invitation.

Oh, no problem. I did have a funny thing, actually, just quickly on the synthetic insight piece. I’ll give you a really good example. One of the use cases that’s being marketed the hardest is that you can get insights into extremely hard-to-research subgroups.

So, for example, in B2B, CFOs are a notoriously difficult group to get access to, to do any kind of research with. And so there’s this promise that, oh, we will create this panel of CFOs for you and all that stuff. Now, what’s super interesting is, what is the data that that synthetic CFO is built from?

It is typically not anything that has been said by the members of those subgroups themselves. It is entirely built from what’s been written about them by others.

Oof.

So your synthetic CFO is actually built from things like PwC reports on CEO attitudes, and consulting thought leadership, and professional bodies who are writing about surveys of CFOs, whatever. So all of what you are now basing your decision on is being filtered through the economic incentives of whoever wrote about that subgroup, not the subgroup itself. Now, that’s not to say it’s not valuable.

It can be valuable to synthesize all of the things that are being said about CFOs. But we should view it as such. We shouldn’t view it as, oh, this is what CFOs think. And then multiply that by any subgroup, right? Skater kids in the city. You’re not getting what skater kids in the city think of themselves. You’re getting everything that’s being written about them by others.

It’s amazing. The level of distortion that happens naturally as a result of that is really quite staggering.

And I’m not a doomer on this stuff. I just think it’s about eyes wide open. Because what the LLM and the AI systems give you seems so plausible.It makes it so believable. And that’s very dangerous. I think that plausibility is very problematic when the underlying data that it’s reflecting is potentially extremely biased.

Yeah. And you’ve talked about this, I can’t remember if it was in another conversation we had. I was thinking about this, the idea of fidelity. If plausibility is the risk, what do you actually need? Is it fidelity? And you’ve talked about the unique human, being certifiably human. Is that your language?

Yeah. I think that we’re very, very quickly going to arrive at a place where, if you’re in the business of doing research with people, you have to have an audit trail that can prove that the people you are talking to are real and not synthetic.

Right. People are signing in to do online research, and it’s an avatar. It’s not a real human. And doing a Zoom call, a video call. Because, I don’t know, what’s the average these days to participate in something like that?

75 bucks.

75 bucks. So if you can sign up for 100 of these things, and chuck an AI avatar in there, and pay a few dollars in token usage, and you get 75, that’s seven and a half thousand.

Yeah. It’s mind-blowing. And I’ve read pieces that polls and surveys are also getting overrun.

Because you can just fill it in. And there’s a video on YouTube, I can’t remember the journalist, but they were looking at how a lot of the fairly extremist content, the binary stuff that gets everybody outraged online, actually originates in the developing world, because they’re monetizing it. And so they don’t really care. They literally have no dog in this fight.

Right.

All they’re doing is trying to make some money, because they earn almost nothing. And the monetization relative to where they live is quite significant, right?

And I think it’s not hard to say that almost certainly the exact same thing is happening to survey responses, Zoom-based research. If you have ready access to the technology, and you’re smart, and you’re hungry for money, you’re going to figure it out.

100%. Awesome. Thank you.

Yeah, no problem. It’s all good. It sounds doomy, but I don’t mean it that way. I actually think there’s going to be real value in being able to show the supply chain for research.

This has been so much fun.

Thanks.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?